Monday, September 01, 2014
   
Text Size

Search our Site or Google

Trading Algorithms: Automated “Stupid Money”

Articles & Blogs - US Commentary

User Rating: / 13
PoorBest 

I was recently watching a report on Canada's Business News Network (BNN), which was attempting to show how “flash-trading” (i.e. giving insiders advance information on orders and prices) was “bad”, but “high-frequency trading” (i.e. allowing a computer algorithm to trade for you) was “good”.


To discuss this issue, BNN interviewed a woman named Irene Aldridge, who had written a book on this subject. Sadly, the talking-heads in the North American media tend to assume that when someone has written a book on a subject that this makes them an unquestioned “expert” - with the talking-head generally allowing such people to make any assertions they want, unchallenged.


In this case, the author interviewed by BNN made the sweeping statement that the only difference between a trading algorithm and human trader was that the trading algorithm was faster – meaning we should all embrace the “efficiencies” these programs bring to trading. The author assured BNN that these algorithms “knew everything” that those doing the programming knew.


Ironically, one of the limitations of new technology is a lack of understanding of the limitations of new technology. We all know that a computer can be programmed to play chess as well as any human, so why can't computers handle most/all of our trading for us?


While I'm no computer programmer, my background in mathematics means I have a much better understanding of algorithms than your average person. I can state unequivocally that there are enormous differences between creating software to play chess, and creating software to trade markets.


The most important difference is that a chess game is a closed system! In a chess game, there is no possibility of any exogenous events upsetting the program through introducing unexpected variables. Conversely, in trading markets there are literally an infinite number of exogenous events which can impact markets and introduce totally unique parameters at any given moment.


From political and economic events, to extreme weather and natural disasters (and any combination of those parameters) there is an endless list of events which can occur on any given day. To make our world more complicated still, there is no way to predict how such events will be reported. If a hurricane and an important political event occur at the same time, there is no way to know in advance which news item will be stressed more in news-reporting, meaning there is no way to know which of these events will have a relatively larger impact on markets.


In addition, the number of possible “moves” in a chess game are not only finite, but in terms of computers, represent a very limited number of options. Conversely, markets literally present infinite possible “moves”, and infinite possible outcomes. It is impossible (even for a computer) to make optimal decisions in a system with infinite possibilities. At best, it could make near-optimal decisions, most of the time. However, during times of extreme events (such as we experienced last year), inevitably these programs make worse decisions than a real person, most likely aggravating periods of crisis like we just experienced.


This alone is more than enough to invalidate all trading algorithms, with respect to their ability to handle atypical scenarios. The moment an algorithm is forced to perform in circumstances which are outside of its programming, these algorithms descend into chaos – where suddenly there is no way to predict how the algorithm will behave. Allowing dozens of these algorithms to function, with thousands (or ten's of thousands, or hundred's of thousands) of individual traders operating them doesn't make markets more “efficient”. Instead, the algorithms, themselves become unpredictable variables which do nothing but amplify volatility.


However, this is only the beginning of my objections to a system which has done nothing but automate “stupid money”. After all the market “experts” (the same “experts” who design trading algorithms) finished exclaiming how “surprised” they were – when the largest asset-bubble in human history burst, they have spent an equal amount of time pointing out how “unprecedented” recent events have been. How exactly can a programmer program a mindless computer to handle situations which the programmer has never experienced in his own life?


The answer, of course, is that he can't. Thus, the trading algorithms have been woefully inadequate to handle recent conditions in markets. Rather than making markets more “efficient”, they have simply made markets more unpredictable as these algorithms blindly stumble through each trading day, making buying and selling decisions which they lack the experience and understanding to make in a rational, optimal manner.


Worse yet, these algorithms all incorporate the implicit assumption that we have “free and open markets”. As I have pointed out several times, most recently in “Insider-selling STILL accelerating”, it is utterly ludicrous to suggest that the United States has “free markets”, when its common knowledge they have their own “Team” of manipulators interfering in markets every day, while a mere handful of banker/broker oligarchs literally control most of the trading. I read one estimate that 75% of all U.S. equities trading flows through Wall Street.


How do trading algorithms react to manipulated markets? I have no idea, since none of these algorithms have any programming to guide them in how they should behave. However, with both the Plunge Protection Team and the Wall Street crime syndicate being completely familiar with all these algorithms, and (as the manipulators) also having full knowledge of exactly how trading has been distorted (by themselves), it is even easier to lead these trading algorithms around 'by the nose' than the reckless lemmings known as “retail investors”.


Thus, the reason why the Wall Street crime syndicate is such an enthusiastic supporter of high-frequency trading is because it makes it even easier to “game” the markets. Additional support comes from a long list of other market participants, who blindly endorse these programs (despite having no understanding of their limitations) – simply because it is easier.


The argument in favor of trading algorithms cannot be based on “efficiency” or “practicality”, since these programs are neither efficient nor practical. Indeed, ultimately the only real arguments in favor of these stupid, computer programs are based upon greed and laziness. Quite obviously, these are considerations which do not lead to favorable outcomes for most market participants.

Trackback(0)
Comments (0)Add Comment

Write comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy

Latest Commentary

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12

Latest Comments

Disclaimer:

BullionBullsCanada.com is not a registered investment advisor - Stock information is for educational purposes ONLY. Bullion Bulls Canada does not make "buy" or "sell" recommendations for any company. Rather, we seek to find and identify Canadian companies who we see as having good growth potential. It is up to individual investors to do their own "due diligence" or to consult with their financial advisor - to determine whether any particular company is a suitable investment for themselves.

Login Form

increasing dosage of celexa buying myambutol from canada no prescription amoxil buy india order abilify medication pharmacy metformin where to get viagra for sex actonel brand positioning is kamagra a prescription drug buy abortion pill what does acai juice taste like pharmacies atarax anxiety sedation viagra legal dubai can you buy order benicar hct low cost maxaman g flow herbal erection pills cleocin without a perscription acheter minocin elimite roche precio argentina can reglan make you gain weight como comprar ginseng myambutol order online no prescription retin a amazon.co.uk order caverta online uk viagra price philippines stromectol 3mg information silagra bonus pills antabuse health canada what is the correct dosage of levlen how to take cymbalta furosemide buy online ireland viagra looking for rogaine boots uk revia delivery london www.medspills.com ventolin medicine guide brand advair diskus prices at costco roxithromycin not generic generic from lipothin buy brand januvia missed lithium dose diovan tablets used buy 120 pack price alli canadian pharmacy glucotrol xl tadacip tablets colospa roche precio argentina is simvastatin better than rosuvastatin diarex in croatia how to get accutane drug us online pharmacy no prescription lioresal plavix tablets on line to buy best blood pressure medication for diabetics septilin online order buying menosan in manchester order cialis with paypal account buy seroflo quick what does tegretol treat does medicare cover viagra 2013 what is the generic drug for vytorin can you buy shallaki in ireland carbozyne discount voucher what is the medication coumadin used for cheap brand amoxil pills plavix drugs canada weight gain while taking arimidex what is nitrofurantoin mono mac 100mg caps used for long time side effects innopran xl topamax cost cvs antivert drug class buy keflex inhaler canada can you order prednisolone online without where can i buy griseofulvin for cats what type of medication is coreg buy ceftin capsules better than revatio lexapro cheap online viagra from india what is the dosage for hyaluronic acid all types lasix pills buy himalaya mentat buy retino-a cream 0,05 online from usa lamictal tablets 25 mg non prescription diarex pharmacy arthritis cure aspirin zyban women buy how long to take doxycycline for uti mail order wellbutrin lanoxin tablets us online what is cipro good for what is diclofenac sodium enteric coated tablets nolvadex coupons glyciphage from franco indian metformin abilify dosage depression nitroglycerin prescription drug nexium esomeprazole obat drug market order propranolol i pill cozaar website albuterol sulfate 0.083 nebulizer solution dosage albuterol sulfate generic alli no prescription i pill cipla composition what is bentyl drug buy bactroban from canada long term side effects of seroquel metformin 1000 mg tab evista dosage too high why is there a shortage of albenza mobic medication wikipedia prednisone buy australia viramune mg tablet f1 online drugstore baku lopid pas cher italie l-tryptophan prices cvs the online drugstore actos anafranil us companies only kytril where to get order non generic celebrex best site get diclofenac generic cymbalta paypal buy tamoxifen citrate nolvadex cheap price where to tretinoin 0,05 trental mg price safe to buy generic motilium from usa compare prices apcalis sx sinemet price generic abilify 5mg silagra 5mg tablets is confido a prescription drug buy generic celexa with bonus viagra cialis price comparison diovan pharmacy order synthroid 0.125 mg tablet adalat in canada is differin gel or cream better toradol on line purchase stress and anxiety symptoms imitrex medication assistance cheap ampicillin 500 mg is there a generic for estrace maximale dosering strattera where to buy allegra d pharmacy will medicare part d pay for viagra side effects of anastrozole tablets buy benicar 20 mg zantac over the counter for children alphagan coupon code capoten dosage recommended triamcinolone acetonide cream uses poison ivy comprar viagra soft online amaryl mg price best kamagra chewable prices fertomid order xeloda pharmacy coupons buying advair in mexico ventolin evohaler 100 micrograms pl proventil medicine is generic benzac effective buy trazodone pills in the australia how to take keflex capsules altace side effects cough estrace to buy buying oxytrol in manchester trileptal delivery citalopram canadian online pletal shopping probalan pill shortage us online pharmacy no prescription levitra professional where to buy olanzapine ointment cost of ventolin inhaler without insurance lasuna australia price augmentin 875 mg 125 mg tabletki powlekane mail order pharmacy tech jobs florida online pharmacy no prescription needed pariet how to order brand viagra online periactin online bestellen glyburide and pregnancy risks american pravachol evista medication overnight delivery ranitidine medicine side effects augmentin dosage how many days sustiva generic 2013 drugs pulmicort roche precio argentina levofloxacin 500 mg cost buspar tablets for purchase hyaluronic acid in croatia donde comprar plavix is ceftin better than augmentin buy dilantin in ireland erexin-v shopping order flomax without rx lexapro dosage for children best price for prednisolone risperdal medication dementia buy cheap fertility drugs what is cialis pills wiki ditropan online meds buy kamagra uk reviews lopressor for daily use canada acheter bactroban pas cher celexa weight loss side effects flomax international limited new zealand online pharmacy pamelor health canada brand cialis vermox shoppers drug mart entocort discount card pfizer offer of discount lipitor prompts outcry lipitor store drugs drugstore 1 man 1 jar video download how to use alligator clips in hair buy cozaar paypal how much does celebrex cost in canada cheap moduretic free delivery buy styplon perth australia cost of flovent cfd can you get pregnant while on celexa moduretic billig kaufen discount pharmacy canberra macquarie how to buy flagyl er in london lamisil generic for sale entocort tablets side effects trandate cheap uk buy prescription drugs with paypal luvox cr discounts mobic without insurance how much prednisone is too much for dogs can you buy levlen online donde puedo comprar metformina en mexico voltaren italiano nitroglycerin spray buy online calan order in the us can i get deltasone carafate over counter is 100mg of zoloft a high dose online generic acticin altace online overnight shipping hytrin for men sale in uk cheap eurax usa ayurslim in croatia plendil australia canadian online pharmacy for imitrex flagyl er uses medication where can i buy kamagra london best herbal alternative to viagra buy claritin d uk prescription erection packs 1 voveran non perscription countries wellbutrin sr weight gain or loss duetact diabetes medication seroxat withdrawal effects how much is evecare tablets viagra over the counter london next day clomid without iui most reliable place to buy bentyl online worldwide pharmacy schools minocin online bestellen generic for paxil side effects clonidine cost comparison costco drug prices 3v lithium battery shelf life promethazine theoclate avomine can you get addicted to phenergan can you open neurontin capsules where do i diovan in australia actos lawsuit settlement amount advair steroid side effects hydrochlorothiazide needed buy buy abilify greece brand levitra tablets uses best place buy nizoral flomax canada pharmacy pills stop period pain sinequan generic wild ginseng prices 2010 order live butterflies for wedding how to order lioresal online generic prednisolone suspension substitution cialis sublingual express canada toprol xl bonus pills phenazopyridine hydrochloride pyridium india cipla products usa asthma inhalers no prescription hydromorphone hydrochloride vs oxycodone can you get zyloprim over the counter lisinopril results forum colchicine australia generic celebrex buy canada buy oxytrol cheap 1 guy 1 jar video youtube is generic wellbutrin sr effective zestril lisinopril tablets levitra fast usa what does calcium carbonate and hydrochloric acid make levlen order online do people buy zoloft lopressor comprar singulair dosage lipothin online uk boots pharmacy uk head office pharmacy that sells cozaar birth control pills taken out of order lilly cialis coupons buy femara with paypal blueberry 100 sildenafil forum benfotiamine dosage too high online pharmacy uk ponstel nootropil 800 mg 30 film tablet powergra 100mg order accutane online pharmacy generic zyrtec 20 mg oxytrol prescription only american pharmacies online and the affiliate websites no rx pyridium online geriforte dosage too high how to by seroquel online how long does it take for sinemet to leave your system where can i get stromectol acquisto torsemide sicuro online reputable online viagra store diflucan per cosa si usa motilium from uk alesse roche precio argentina seroflo 10 mg plendil without rx propecia pills for hair loss purchase finpecia lowest price generic cialis online mastercard can buy duphalac online purinethol tablets side effects what are zoloft pills viagra rezeptfrei kaufen forum lipothin looking for online pharmacy arimidex order cialis from india research grade entocort cipro 1000 india propranolol price entocort mg buy side effects of plavix mexico albendazole pilex ordering online pharmacy minocycline hcl reviews matrimonio a cipro valido in italia buy lamisil mg cozaar 25 mg tablets is quibron-t legal in uk withdrawal from reglan generic name for kamagra gold citalopram prescription information plendil 5 mg prospect india viagra generic how to get aspirin drug what does lamisil what is the drug compazine used for valacyclovir 500 mg caplets best price levitra uk zoloft sale online order fucidin 120 mg best site to buy keflex furosemide online usa no prescription tadapox medicine children calcium carbonate next day delivery naltrexone alcohol sinclair method atorvastatin cost effective what is maxalt mlt 10 mg for testosterone cream side effects heart what is doxycycline medication used for buy allopurinol online at canada pharmacy canadian female viagra order non generic diovan Purchase actos 30mg pioglitazone can i make mevacor is mail order rogaine 5 safe homeopathy medicine brahmi where can i buy acai berries in the uk evecare prices usa prednisone side effects cats long term altace generico online duphalac syrup india bentyl ibs what does the medicine provera do prandin refill pack celexa anxiety disorder fast sominex deleviery ordering actos here in canada can you get cymbalta in canada special care pharmacy puerto rico efficacy and safety of the weight loss drug rimonabant prescriptions buy ceftin overnight voltaren online buy can doxycycline help you get pregnant buy abana online reviews buy suprax 200 mg buy online fml forte generic lasix generico online benzac ac over counter generic drug for prilosec mobic lawsuit settlements bystolic no prescription canada sambazon freeze-dried acai capsules 75 capsules buy dramamine cvs nexium not generic purchase robaxin in india clarithromycin side effects nhs do i need a prescription for fertomid pharmacie en ligne suisse keppra vs levetiracetam side effects generic confido switzerland bupron sr by mail order casodex reviews voveran sr pas cher skelaxin discount medications tronchetti provera wiki lortab side effects anger pharmacy has best price paxil buy alli online canada diet retino a 0.025 or 0.05 floxin uk boots aygestin from usa mobic prices at costco phenergan 25 mg iv para que se usa el antibiotico cephalexin motilium over the counter drugs generic cleocin switzerland non persciption reglan nizagara pills drugstore buy cordarone online in usa voltaren ec tablets 50mg side effects zyrtec 100 count cheapest voltaren paypal generic uk paypal vasotec paxil lowest price order cordarone 120 mg trazodone maximum dosage for sleep liquid penegra review chloramphenicol reviews for men buy cialis super active without rx xenical cost comparison over the counter keftab clomiphene for men dose orlistat xenical coversyl plus tablets is lipitor now a generic citalopram costco desyrel online pay paypal generic diabecon switzerland toprol generic problem buy worldwide clonidine mg buy micardis hct 80 betnovate cream ingredients get viagra plus las vegas kamagra pharmacy prices list where to buy oxytrol buy atarax online overnight generic levitra free shipping purchase tetracycline mg finpecia prices at costco nizoral 200mg tabletten dosierung generic ophthacare safe buy actonel online in usa vet-vipps certification generic uk paypal pletal canadian no prescription drugs can order mentax online clavamox 500 mg bactroban generic reviews keflex alcohol ashwagandha online forum keftab doctors online comprare silagra armour thyroid medication uk wellbutrin sr women buy generic clomid canada did bob dole do viagra commercial xenical price in lebanon how much is nizoral tablets cytotec dosage for labor induction new mexico alliance for school-based health care strattera dosage adults where to get mentax pct buy alavert flagyl comprimidos nin~os nexium medication coupons yasmin low dose estrogen purchase citalopram on line in australia purchase female viagra cheap buy arava paypal low price lisinopril uk diflucan in canada over the counter order toprol online no prescription with a visa purim tablets price lasuna online in usa buy avodart online cheap liposafe express canada walmart alliston store hours generic drugs today brand names fda citrato de sildenafila 50mg e' bom can you order beconase aq patient spray lanoxin delivery american express merchant login australia reviews on sinemet zenegra online coupon code vasotec pharmacy aclu supports citizens united how to use erythromycin topical solution usp 2 get zantac las vegas proventil from india finpecia cost in india azithromycin z pack breastfeeding buy nizagara online no prescription uk buy propranolol from mexico online implicane side effects what type of medication is amantadine buy starlix australia trandate 100mg tablet ranitidine hcl cost insurance times awards synthroid online coupon code low price brand advair diskus uk zanaflex for sale prazosin with no rx common side effects of yasmin aspirin over counter dose orlistat weight loss pills capsules 120mg cheapest place to buy forzest lasuna buy online ireland voveran 100mg side effects buy cephalexin low cheap price what is benadryl used for in children all types septilin pills is lanoxin a generic or brand name buy online zyrtec generic januvia express canada buy cytotec online no prescription canada over the counter alternative to lisinopril buy super kamagra uk motilium m 10 mg online zovirax overnight delivery generic prograf availability sildenafilo cinfa 25 mg famvir western australia generic for levlen generic drug name norvasc nootropil mist canada very cheap atorlip-5 northwest pharmacy promo coupon code buy paroxetine tablets alli from usa how to use ortho tri-cyclen as morning after pill buy ranitidine for daily use health canada aldactone healthy chicken with mango salsa recipe buy viramune in singapore generic vs. brand name valtrex ordering propecia online broan nutone med cabinets cleocin tablets purchase on line amaryl m2 tablet side effects side effects of norvasc blood pressure medication buy evista tablets uk can you take voltaren daily nature;s plus acai liquid reviews coreg cr discounts generic metformin buy canada buy vermox 40 side effects of terramycin for cats comprar arava original sale cafergot atorlip-5 tablets uses is aciclovir available on line in canada jobs in cipla pharmaceutical company where can i get my orlistat prescription buy fosamax pills tadacip sale pharmacy cheapest premarin costco pharmacy cymbalta discount price to buy astelin azelastine drug methocarbamol 750 mg tab discount canadian pharmacy ceftin cialis super active how to buy pregnancy post accutane treatment fast effexor xr delivery buy naprosyn line comprar avalide portugal taking isotretinoin alcohol cheapest place to buy hydrochlorothiazide herbal viagra alternative cost of wellbutrin at walgreens novolog insulin pen prices how much does prednisone for cats cost alli diet medication reviews is there a drug comparative to baclofen order prescriptions online boots buy yasmin boots pharmacy buy ayurslim capsules order fincar online uk cymbalta price in mexico rosuvastatin online meds online pharmacy uk buspar clonidine medication where to buy canadian plendil buy cheap clomid usa how long does it take for metformin to help with pcos desi tashan madhubala 8th march 2013 how to get lotrisone drug buy lasix pills in the mexico is celebrex available in canada does mircette help acne buy didronel online pharmacy buy atacand online in usa cheap antivert 25mg finasteride generico colombia prednisone cost no insurance buy zyloprim with e check purchase crestor 10mg online acai berry tablets wiki aciclovir on line in the mexico where to buy augmentin online canada prograf medication guide why has prograf been discontinued ciplox cost in canada order calcium carbonate tablets can i order yaz online how to take zyrtec liquid gels where to buy acai berry diet pills what is lithium batteries used for decadron dose for poison ivy is there a generic lexapro 2011 where to get morning after pill suppliers of detrol in us celebrex dosage and administration diflucan online australia discount zestril without prescription order adalat one pharmacy viagra professional prix en pharmacie en france most common side effects of methotrexate where can i buy alli right now? comprar viagra sublingual online what is the generic for allegra d low dose amitriptyline doctor elocon pill shortage motilium from usa lamisil pharmacy nail emsam withdrawal side effects